Domestic Violence Act Explained: Women’s Right to Reside in Shared Household Post-Divorce

Title: Ashish v. Mohini: Key Takeaways from the Bombay High Court's Landmark Judgment on Shared Household Rights

Introduction
In the recent case of Ashish v. Mohini, Criminal Revision Application No. 240 of 2022, the Bombay High Court made significant observations regarding the rights of women in a shared household under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (DV Act). The case centered on the entitlement of a wife and mother to reside in the shared household of her deceased husband. The Court's ruling reinforced the interpretation of “domestic relationship” and “shared household” under the DV Act, and its implications for women facing domestic violence.

Case Background: A Family Dispute Over Property
The applicant, Ashish, was in a legal dispute with the non-applicant, Mohini, regarding her right to reside in the shared household following the death of her husband, who was Ashish’s brother. The non-applicant, along with her minor son, sought permission to live in the house but was denied entry by Ashish.

The deceased had bequeathed the ground floor to Ashish and the first floor to himself under his mother's will. The non-applicant and her husband had previously lived together in the shared household but had moved out in 2004 due to a family dispute. After the death of her husband in 2008, Mohini and her son sought to return to the property, but Ashish objected, claiming that she never resided with her husband in the house.

The non-applicant filed a petition under Section 12 of the DV Act seeking relief, but the Judicial Magistrate First Class (JMFC) initially rejected her application. She appealed the decision, and the Additional Sessions Judge ruled in her favor. Ashish then filed a revision application before the Bombay High Court.

Key Legal Issue: Can a Woman Claim Residence in a Shared Household Even After Divorce or Separation?
One of the central issues in this case was whether the non-applicant had a legal right to reside in the shared household, despite her separation from her husband, the deceased, and her current residence in rented accommodation. The applicant argued that she had never lived in the house with her husband and that there was a divorce decree between them.

However, the Bombay High Court, while examining the provisions of the DV Act, found that a woman has the right to reside in the shared household even if she had previously lived there and even if the domestic relationship had ended.

Court's Interpretation of "Shared Household" and "Domestic Relationship"
The Court emphasized that the words “has lived together at any point of time” under Section 17 of the DV Act cover past cohabitation, making the application maintainable as long as the parties had lived together in a domestic relationship, irrespective of whether they lived together at the time of filing the petition.

The Court referred to the precedent set in Prabha Tyagi v. Kamlesh Devi (2022) 8 SCC 90, reaffirming that a woman in a domestic relationship, irrespective of her marital status, is entitled to reside in the shared household. It also reiterated that the DV Act is a social welfare legislation designed to protect women from domestic violence and ensure their constitutional rights, including the right to reside in a shared household.

The Court clarified that even a woman not subjected to domestic violence could claim this right to reside in the shared household. This interpretation ensures that women are not deprived of their rightful place in the family home due to domestic disputes or separation.

Key Takeaways from the Court’s Decision

• Past Cohabitation Counts: A woman has the right to reside in a shared household even if she has not been living there at the time of filing the petition, as long as there was a domestic relationship at some point.

• Right to Residence is Absolute: Women in a domestic relationship have the right to reside in the shared household, irrespective of the ownership of the property.

• No Need for Continuous Cohabitation: The DV Act's provisions cover past cohabitation, meaning that a woman does not lose her right to reside in the household simply because she had moved out years ago.

• Dissolution of Marriage Must Be Through a Civil Court: The Court rejected the applicant’s claim that the non-applicant was divorced based on a divorce deed, stating that divorce can only be decreed by a competent civil court.

Conclusion: Protecting Women's Rights under the DV Act
The Bombay High Court's ruling reinforces the protective measures available to women under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005. It clarifies that the right to reside in a shared household is not dependent on actual cohabitation but rather on the existence of a domestic relationship. This ruling is a critical step toward ensuring that women can claim their rightful place in the family home, even after separation or divorce.

For women who are facing similar situations, it is important to understand their legal rights under the DV Act. If you're going through a domestic dispute, a divorce, or facing domestic violence, you are entitled to legal protection, including the right to reside in a shared household.

Contact a Lawyer for Legal Assistance
If you're dealing with complex domestic violence issues or matrimonial disputes, it’s crucial to consult with an experienced lawyer who specializes in family law.

Advocate Devashish Maharishi – Expert in Divorce case & Domestic Violence Cases

Best Divorce case Lawyer in karkardooma Court Delhi

If you need legal help for any of the following matters:

• Mutual Consent Divorce or Contested Divorce

• Domestic Violence Protection under the DV Act

• Maintenance or Alimony Cases

• Child Custody Disputes

• Transfer Petition Cases before the Supreme Court of India

• NRI Divorce Cases

📍 Office Address: 137, J-Extension, Laxmi Nagar, Delhi, 110092
📞 Contact: +91 8595722509

• Domestic violence case lawyer

• Divorce lawyer in Delhi

• Best Divorce Lawyer

• Maintenance case Lawyer

• Alimony case Lawyer

• Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act

• Shared Household rights under DV Act

• Family disputes lawyer Delhi

• Domestic abuse legal help